Careers
Favorites
Advertise With Us
Log In
Home / Milwaukee Area Apartments / West Allis / 5309 W Hayes Ave
16 Photos
Photos (16)
Photos Floor Plans
Never miss out on places like this.
Create an account to get alerts when new listings become available in the West Allis area.
Email address:

Error! Please try again later.
Updated over 1 month ago
Contact property manager for current availability

5309 W Hayes Ave


West Allis, WI

Bed
•
Bath
Floor plans
2 Beds • 1 Bath
$1,095
950 ft2
0 Available
Managed By: ShowMojo
Spacious Two Bedroom Upper Duplex
$1,095
Rented
View
Where you'll live
Street View
Map View
Satellite View
5309 W Hayes Ave
5309 W Hayes Ave
5309 W Hayes Ave
Location ratings
Walk Score®
52
Somewhat Walkable
Transit Score®
41
Some Transit
Bike Score®
50
Bikeable
Property details
Additional Details
Total Unit Count: 1
Last Updated: Updated over 1 month ago
Contact Number: (262) 404-3915
Message Sent.
A confirmation email has been sent to your inbox.
More Properties Like This
$1,045
2426 S. 35Th St
Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | May. 1, 2026
1.1 miles away
$800 - $1,150
6901-13 W Mitchell St
West Allis, WI
Studio - 2 BR | Available Now
1.3 miles away
$1,350
2329-2359 S 51st St. (32 Unit)
2329-2359 S 51st St Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
0.2 miles away
$1,100
2027 S 76Th St
West Allis, WI
2 BR | May. 1, 2026
1.5 miles away
$1,147
Grand Avenue Lofts
2905 W Wisconsin Ave Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
3.0 miles away
$1,081
Bishops Creek Family Housing
4765 N 32nd St Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | May. 6, 2026
7.2 miles away
$1,100
4244 Wilson Drive
4244 Wilson Dr Shorewood, WI
2 BR | Available Now
7.6 miles away
$1,123 - $1,397
Mckinley Gardens
2014-2022 W Vliet St Milwaukee, WI
2 - 4 BR | Available Now
3.9 miles away
$1,100
Mayfair Manor
11040 W. Meinecke Ave Wauwatosa, WI
2 BR | May. 1, 2026
5.6 miles away
$1,149
White Swan
3413-3439 S 26th St Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
2.1 miles away
$1,020
3051 Fardale
3051 W Fardale Ave Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
2.2 miles away
$1,100
2421-2423 W Finn Pl
Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
6.0 miles away
View More Apartments in West Allis
Report an Issue
Tell us who you are:
Issue type:
Additional Information:

Issue has been submitted
Error! Please try again later.
Photos Floor Plans
Renters Also Viewed
$800 - $1,150
6901-13 W Mitchell St
West Allis, WI
Studio - 2 BR | Available Now
1.3 miles away
$1,350
2329-2359 S 51st St. (32 Unit)
2329-2359 S 51st St Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
0.2 miles away
$1,300
Westgrand Apartments
Miller Park Way West Milwaukee, WI
2 BR | Available Now
1.1 miles away
$1,379 - $3,451
The West Living
6700 West National Avenue West Allis, WI
Studio - 2 BR | Apr. 18, 2026
1.3 miles away
$1,300 - $1,400
Orchard Park Apartments
6901-6951 W Orchard St West Allis, WI
1 - 2 BR | Apr. 17, 2026
1.4 miles away
Rent report

If you upsized to an average priced West Allis 3 bedroom apartment, you would pay 6% less per month.

If you downsized to an average priced West Allis 1 bedroom apartment, you would pay 37% less per month.

Monthly Rent Rent per Sq. Ft. Suggested
Monthly Income
West Allis Average
Studio $1,425 $2.70 $4,275
1BR $1,241 $1.70 $3,723
2BR $1,700 $1.60 $5,101
3BR $1,611 $1.30 $4,834

Availability in West Allis

In order to find the best deal, you need to know what types of units are available. Property managers may be willing to give concessions if they have many vacant units.

There are currently 104 2BR units on the market in West Allis. If you're looking to negotiate, this may be your best option.

Studio
1BR
2BR
3BR
9% 37% 46% 8%
Available Units in West Allis
Studio 21
1BR 83
2BR 104
3BR 17
Location
Nearby Colleges

Alverno College

Marquette University

Milwaukee Area Technical College

University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee

Nearby Hospitals
Name Distance
Clement J. Zablocki Va Medical Center 1.41 mi.
Aurora St Lukes Medical Center 1.68 mi.
Select Spec Hospital Lukes Campus 1.7 mi.
Nearby Fire Stations
Name Distance
West Allis Fire Department 1.48 mi.
Greenfield Fire Department 2.99 mi.
Greenfield Fire Department 3.5 mi.
FAQs
Is this property currently leasing units?
No. This property is not currently accepting new tenants.
Does this property allow cats or dogs?
The property manager did not submit a pet policy with this listing.
Where is this property located?
This property is at 5309 W Hayes Ave in West Allis, WI. It's 1.2 miles southeast from the center of West Allis.
Call
Popular Searches
Cities
Neighborhoods
Colleges
More Properties Like This
Other Nearby Searches
Feeling slow?
Not you. The internet, silly.
Get the app for a faster apartment search.
Get the app