535 23rd Ave N

Property Description
Welcome to one of Crescent Heights' most distinguished homes. Winner of the St. Pete Preservation Award for Historic Renovation, this 1920s Colonial was comprehensively restored down to the studs in 2019. It offers the rare combination of authentic historic character and completely modern, worry-free infrastructure.
Located in a highly desirable Non-Evacuation Zone (High & Dry), this home offers peace of mind and an incredible lifestyle. You are just one block from the 54-acre oasis of Crescent Lake Park and a short walk to the city's best amenities, including Trader Joe's, Fresh Market, and downtown dining.
The Home:
Impeccable Restoration: Enjoy the warmth of original hardwood floors and a legacy fireplace alongside modern comforts like professional insulation, impact-rated windows, and high-efficiency dual-zone HVAC.
Chef's Layout: The first floor features a formal foyer, a sun-drenched home office (wrapped in windows), and a spacious living room. The open-concept eat-in kitchen connects to a cozy den, featuring a gas range, convection microwave, and a dedicated laundry room.
Private Retreats: The second floor hosts a generous Primary Suite with a walk-in closet and en-suite bath, plus two additional bedrooms and a full hall bath.
Bonus Living Space: A fully climate-controlled third floor offers massive flexibility perfect as a 4th bedroom, playroom, media room, or private guest quarters.
Outdoor Living: Step out through double doors to a private, fenced courtyard an ideal spot for grilling or evening relaxation. A dedicated walkway leads to the rear alley.
Parking & Storage: Includes dedicated off-street parking for two vehicles behind the house. A new, watertight storage shed is provided for bicycles, kayaks, sports gear and other general storage.
The Neighborhood & Lifestyle:
Leave the car at home. You are minutes from St. Pete's best lifestyle hubs:
1 Block: Crescent Lake Park (Running paths, pickleball, tennis, dog park, and playground).
Walkable Dining & Grocery: Trader Joe's, Fresh Market, Rolling Oats, Casita Taqueria, Trip's Diner, Calida Kitchen, Golden Isles Brewing, La Segunda, Athenian Gardens, and more.
Commute Ready: Easy access to I-275 and Downtown St. Pete.
Lease Terms & Management
Boutique Management: We are local owners living next door who self-manage a small, curated portfolio. You get the best of both worlds: professional, responsive service without the red tape of a large agency. We have a trusted team of specialists for any maintenance needs.
Inclusions: Professional landscape and lawn service is included. Residents are responsible for utilities.
Policies: Pet friendly (with approval and pet fee). Strictly non-smoking property.
Requirements: We value long-term relationships and are happy to provide references from past and current residents. Complete credit, background, and reference checks are required for all applicants.
We are local owners who self-manage this home as part of a small, curated portfolio of luxury properties in the neighborhood. We offer a boutique rental experience: we know the house intimately, are located nearby, and employ a dedicated network of professional tradespeople to address maintenance needs immediately. Landscape and lawn service is included to ensure pristine curb appeal. Residents handle utilities. This is a strict smoke-free property. We are pet-friendly and value long-term relationships with our residents references from past and current tenants are happily provided. Thorough credit, background, and reference checks are standard for all applicants. Please respect the privacy of our current residents.