3505 Prairie Ave

Two Kitchens!
Perfect for Roommates or Multi-Gen Living
Available August/September, 2026
Looking to split rent with friends? Need two households under one roof? This fully updated 4-bedroom, 2-bath home on Madison's East Side is one of the few rentals in the city designed for it.
The setup: The main floor features a beautifully updated full kitchen, two bedrooms, and a full bath. The lower level has its own completely separate living space: two more bedrooms, a full bathroom, a living room, and a second kitchen with a full stove/oven, large sink, microwave, and fridge. Two groups can share the home comfortably without sharing a kitchen.
We owned this home for five years and updated nearly everything before renting it: appliances, cabinetry, flooring, paint, bathrooms, windows, both kitchens, and the yard.
What you get:
- Two full kitchens (upper + lower suite)
- 4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms / ~1,400 sq ft
- In-unit washer/dryer
- Central air & heat
- Large fenced backyard with deck
- Fenced front garden plot + 2 raised garden beds in back
- Driveway + 1-car garage (free off-street parking)
- Garbage, recycling & sewer included
- Energy-efficient: triple-pane windows, extra attic & wall insulation
- Quiet, low-traffic street
Location: Bike to Madison College Truax Campus, East Towne Mall, and major east-side arteries without the Beltline headache.
Move-in date: Flexible between August-September 2026. Let us know what you're looking for.
Tenant responsibilities: Snow removal, lawn maintenance, and all utilities beyond water, garbage, recycling, and sewer.
Schedule a showing: https://www.avail.co/l/61119663
Applicant requirements:
No late rental payments in last 2 years · No early lease terminations · No lease violations in last 2 years · Monthly income 3× rent · No smoking · No pets