Apartments in 11706

Bay Shore:
May Rent Report

Welcome to the May 2025 Bay Shore Apartment Report. In this assessment of the local rental market, Rentable data scientists and rental experts break down the May 2025 key findings and figures for the Bay Shore rental landscape.

Our experts analyze the pricing trends — one-bedroom, two-bedroom, year-over-year and month-over-month — in Bay Shore and surrounding areas and provide comparisons to the entire metro area, nearby cities and some of the most desirable and expensive cities in the United States. Take a look at the last 12 months of Bay Shore average rent prices in the chart below.

May Prices: Bay Shore vs. Surrounding Areas

Rent Prices in Bay Shore and Surrounding Areas

Rent prices have increased in Bay Shore over the last month. But how have the surrounding areas fared when it comes to the recent volatility in apartment prices? Rent prices in 0 of the Bay Shore suburbs increased last month. On the other hand, 0 local areas experienced a decrease in the price of a one-bedroom apartment.

More key findings include:

• Rents did not increase in any of the Bay Shore suburbs

• Rents did not decrease in any of the Bay Shore suburbs.

Data set for Bay Shore and suburbs

Methodology

Each month, using over 1 million Rentable listings across the United States, we calculate the median 1-bedroom and 2-bedroom rent prices by city, state, and nation, and track the month-over-month percent change. To avoid small sample sizes, we restrict the analysis for our reports to cities meeting minimum population and property count thresholds.