Is this property currently leasing units?

Yes. There are 20 available units at this property.

How many units are move-in ready in the next 2 months?

This property has 18 units available for move-in over the next 2 months. 7 units are vacant and ready for immediate occupancy.

What's the square footage of the available units?

The available units range from 400 to 915 square feet.

Does this property allow cats or dogs?

This property allows tenants to keep cats and dogs.

How many bedrooms are in the available units?

There are studio, 1 and 2 bedroom units available.

How many bathrooms are in the available units?

There are 1 bathroom units available.

What's the monthly rent at this property?

Rent on available units ranges from $1,850 to $3,095. Mid Island Apartments has studio units available starting at $1,850, 1 bedroom units available starting at $2,250, and 2 bedroom units available starting at $2,570.

Where is this property located?

This property is at 35 Penataquit Avenue in Bay Shore, NY. It's 0.5 miles northeast from the center of Bay Shore.

Updated 4 hours ago

Mid Island Apartments

35 Penataquit Avenue Bay Shore, NY

Studio - 2 Bed

•

1 Bath

•

400 - 915 Sq. Ft.

•

Available Now

Floor plans

Studios (2)

Studio • 1 Bath

$1,850 - $2,120

400 ft²

2 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0631C

$1,850

Available May 12^th, 2026

View

0651E

$2,120

Available Jun 1^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

1 beds (10)

1 Bed • 1 Bath

$2,250 - $2,490

665 ft²

6 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0072D

$2,420

Available Now

View

3651A

$2,490

Available Now

View

0292D

$2,250

Available May 11^th, 2026

View

0091D

$2,415

Available May 11^th, 2026

View

0272A

$2,375

Available Jun 13^th, 2026

View

0272D

$2,295

Available Jun 21^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

1 Bed • 1 Bath

$2,265 - $2,440

705 ft²

4 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0551F

$2,265

Available Now

View

0691A

$2,420

Available Now

View

0652F

$2,400

Available May 18^th, 2026

View

0731F

$2,440

Available Jun 1^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

2 beds (8)

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,885 - $3,095

875 ft²

3 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0291C

$3,095

Available Now

View

0172C

$2,885

Available Now

View

0211C

$2,965

Available Apr 30^th, 2026

View

View Rented Units

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,570 - $2,645

870 ft²

2 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0111C

$2,645

Available Now

View

0072C

$2,570

Available May 1^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,810 - $2,870

820 ft²

2 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0192C

$2,810

Available Apr 11^th, 2026

View

0112B

$2,870

Available Jun 1^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,875

915 ft²

1 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0572C

$2,875

Available May 1^st, 2026

View

View Rented Units

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,335 - $2,545

400 ft²

0 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0672B

$2,545

Rented

View

0672B

$2,335

Rented

View

2 Beds • 1 Bath

$2,645 - $2,970

840 ft²

0 Available

Managed By: Eagle Rock Management

0672C

$2,690

Rented

View

0612B

$2,665

Rented

View

0611B

$2,655

Rented

View

0712C

$2,845

Rented

View

0671C

$2,645

Rented

View

0591C

$2,875

Rented

View

0571B

$2,970

Rented

View

0611B

$2,740

Rented

View

Where you'll live

Street View

Map View

Satellite View

Location ratings

Walk Score®

Somewhat Walkable

Bike Score®

Somewhat Bikeable

Amenities

In-unit Laundry

On-site Laundry

Air Conditioning

Refrigerator

Hardwood Floors

Smoke Free

Online Payments

Smoke-free Community

Online Community Portal

On-site Maintenance

Professional On-site Management

Short Term Lease

Cable-ready

Stainless Appliances

Playground

24-hour Maintenance

Secured Entry

High-speed Internet

Ceiling Fans

Freezer

Stainless Steel Appliances

Microwave

Range / Oven

Dishwasher

Fees & leasing info

Pets

Dogs Ok

Cats Ok

Pet Friendly Community

Pet Fee: $250

Pet Rent: $50

Breed Restrictions:

No Aggressive Breeds. The following pets are restricted: Snakes, Livestock, Ferrets, Rabbits, and Reptiles. Other pets may also be restricted. Please call the leasing office or speak to one of our Leasing Consultants for further information.

Size Restrictions:

Cat up to 25 lbs. Dog up to 40 lbs.

Number Limit:

Parking

Surface Parking

Off-street Parking

Lease & Fees

Security Deposit:

1 Month

Lease Length:

12 months

Application Fee:

$50

Late Fee:

Property details

Description

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.

Additional Details

Year Built: 1965

Total Unit Count: 232

Last Updated: Updated 4 hours ago

Contact Number: (631) 665-6565

Property manager information

Eagle Rock Management

Ask a question

Office Hours

Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Saturday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM

Contact Mid Island Apartments

$1,850 - $3,095

Check Availability

Report an issue

	Monthly Rent	Rent per Sq. Ft.	Suggested Monthly Income
Mid Island Apartments
Studio	$1,985	$5.00	$5,955
1BR	$2,377	$3.50	$7,131
2BR	$2,839	$3.30	$8,518
Bay Shore Average
Studio	$2,184	$4.90	$6,552
1BR	$2,523	$3.30	$7,569
2BR	$2,967	$3.00	$8,900

Mid Island Apartments

35 Penataquit Avenue Bay Shore, NY

Mid Island Apartments Rent vs. Bay Shore Average

Availability in Bay Shore