Home / Bay Shore / Mid Island Apartments
Video
3604 Photos
Photos Floor Plans Amenities
Updated 20 hours ago

Mid Island Apartments


35 Penataquit Avenue Bay Shore, NY

1 - 2 Bed
•
1 Bath

665 - 875 Sq. Ft.

Available starting Jan. 11th
Studio • 1 Bath
$1,560 - $1,855
400 ft2
0 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
0632B
$1,780
Rented
View
0732E
$1,745
Rented
View
0631E
$1,855
Rented
View
0732E
$1,765
Rented
View
0732E
$1,735
Rented
View
0631E
$1,765
Rented
View
0552D
$1,735
Rented
View
0651E
$1,560
Rented
View
0632E
$1,785
Rented
View
0732B
$1,595
Rented
View
Studio • 1 Bath
$2,750
820 ft2
0 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
3611B
$2,750
Rented
View
1 Bed • 1 Bath
$2,505
665 ft2
2 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
0231A
$2,505
Available Jan 11th, 2026
View
0072D
$2,505
Available Jan 15th, 2026
View
View Rented Units
1 Bed • 1 Bath
$2,510
705 ft2
2 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
0731F
$2,510
Available Jan 16th, 2026
View
0652A
$2,510
Available Jan 19th, 2026
View
View Rented Units
2 Beds • 1 Bath
$3,160
875 ft2
1 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
0172C
$3,160
Available Feb 23rd, 2026
View
View Rented Units
2 Beds • 1 Bath
$3,015
820 ft2
1 Available
Managed By: Eagle Rock Management
0192C
$3,015
Available Apr 1st, 2026
View
View Rented Units
View More
Where you'll live
Street View
Map View
Satellite View
Location ratings
Walk Score®
55
Somewhat Walkable
Bike Score®
48
Somewhat Bikeable
Amenities
In-unit Laundry
On-site Laundry
Air Conditioning
Refrigerator
Hardwood Floors
Smoke Free
Online Payments
Smoke-free Community
Online Community Portal
On-site Maintenance
Professional On-site Management
Short Term Lease
Cable-ready
Stainless Appliances
Playground
24-hour Maintenance
Secured Entry
High-speed Internet
Ceiling Fans
Freezer
Stainless Steel Appliances
Microwave
Range / Oven
Dishwasher
Fees & leasing info
Pets
Dogs Ok
Cats Ok
Pet Friendly Community
Pet Fee: $200
Pet Rent: $50
Breed Restrictions:

No Aggressive Breeds. The following pets are restricted: Snakes, Livestock, Ferrets, Rabbits, and Reptiles. Other pets may also be restricted. Please call the leasing office or speak to one of our Leasing Consultants for further information.

Size Restrictions:

Cat up to 25 lbs. Dog up to 40 lbs.

Number Limit:

2

Parking
Surface Parking
Off-street Parking
Lease & Fees
Security Deposit:

1 Month

Lease Length:

2 months, 3 months, 4 months, 5 months, 6 months, 7 months, 8 months, 9 months, 10 months, 11 months, 12 months, 13 months, 14 months, 15 months, 16 months, 17 months, 18 months, 19 months, 20 months, 21 months, 22 months, 23 months, 24 months

Application Fee:

$50

Late Fee:

5%

Property details
Description

Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.

Additional Details
Year Built: 1965
Total Unit Count: 232
Last Updated: Updated 20 hours ago
Contact Number: (631) 665-6565
Property manager information
Eagle Rock Management
Ask a question
Office Hours
Monday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Saturday: 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM
Photos Floor Plans Amenities
Affordability
To comfortably afford an apartment, we recommend having at least three times your monthy rent in gross household income.
View suggested annual incomes for Mid Island Apartments by bedroom type below.
1 Bedroom
Suggested income:
$90,300
per year
2 Bedroom
Suggested income:
$111,100
per year
Rent report

Mid Island Apartments Rent vs. Bay Shore Average

 Mid Island Apartments      Bay Shore Average
1BR
$2,508
$2,523
$0
$850
$1,700
$2,550
$3,400
2BR
$3,088
$2,967
$0
$1,050
$2,100
$3,150
$4,200

Mid Island Apartments is asking 1% less than the average 1 bedroom apartment in Bay Shore.

If you upsized to an average priced Bay Shore 2 bedroom apartment, you would pay 15% more per month.

If you downsized to an average priced Bay Shore studio apartment, you would pay 16% less per month.

Mid Island Apartments provides 10% less square footage than the average Bay Shore 1 bedroom apartment.

Monthly Rent Rent per Sq. Ft. Suggested
Monthly Income
Mid Island Apartments
1BR $2,508 $3.70 $7,523
2BR $3,088 $3.60 $9,263
Bay Shore Average
Studio $2,184 $4.90 $6,552
1BR $2,523 $3.30 $7,569
2BR $2,967 $3.00 $8,900

Availability in Bay Shore

In order to find the best deal, you need to know what types of units are available. Property managers may be willing to give concessions if they have many vacant units.

There are currently 26 1BR units on the market in Bay Shore. If you're looking to negotiate, this may be your best option.

Studio
1BR
2BR
17% 50% 33%
Available Units in Bay Shore
Studio 9
1BR 26
2BR 17
Location
Nearby Colleges
Nearby Hospitals
Name Distance
Southside Hospital 0.26 mi.
Good Samaritan Hospital West Islip 3.81 mi.
St. Catherine Of Siena Medical Center 9.65 mi.
Nearby Fire Stations
Name Distance
Brentwood Fire Department 0.16 mi.
East Brentwood Fire Department 0.16 mi.
Saltaire Volunteer Fire Company 0.18 mi.
FAQs
Is this property currently leasing units?
Yes. There are 6 available units at this property.
How many units are move-in ready in the next 2 months?
This property has 5 units available for move-in over the next 2 months. The soonest move-in date is January 11, 2026.
What's the square footage of the available units?
The available units range from 665 to 875 square feet.
Does this property allow cats or dogs?
This property allows tenants to keep cats and dogs.
How many bedrooms are in the available units?
There are 1 and 2 bedroom units available.
How many bathrooms are in the available units?
There are 1 bathroom units available.
What's the monthly rent at this property?
Rent on available units ranges from $2,505 to $3,160. Mid Island Apartments has 1 bedroom units available starting at $2,505 and 2 bedroom units available starting at $3,160.
Where is this property located?
This property is at 35 Penataquit Avenue in Bay Shore, NY. It's 0.5 miles northeast from the center of Bay Shore.
Call Email
Feeling slow?
Not you. The internet, silly.
Get the app for a faster apartment search.
Get the app