Careers
Favorites
Advertise With Us
Log In
Create Search Alert
Get alerts when new listings become available in the Monticello area that match this search.
Email address:

Subscribed
Error! Please try again later.
Contact Property
Your Name

Email Address

Phone Number
Desired Move In Date
Desired Number of Bedrooms
Request a Tour Date

Ask a Question

Error! Please try again later.

Apartments in Monticello

1 - 6 of 6 Results
17
$1,850 - 1,950
Anthos Townhomes
1 Richardson Ct Monticello, NY
2 - 3 BR | Available Now
Contact
Dog Friendly
Cat Friendly
House
Storage
26
$2,900
824 State Rt 17 B, Unit Main
Monticello, NY
5 BR | Available Now
Contact
Air Conditioning
Dishwasher
19
$1,700
141 Gale Rd
Mongaup Valley, NY
2 BR | Available Now
Contact
House
Air Conditioning
Balcony/Deck/Patio
Storage
16
$1,700
74 Kitz Rd Unit 74B
Monticello, NY
3 BR | Available Now
Contact
21
$1,250
1 Horseshoe Lake Rd Unit 2
Kauneonga Lake, NY
1 BR | Apr. 1, 2026
Contact
Balcony/Deck/Patio
12
$1,600
74 Kitz Rd Unit 68A
Monticello, NY
2 BR | Available Now
Contact
Dishwasher
1 - 6 of 6 Results
  1. Home
  2. Monticello

How much does it cost to rent an apartment in Monticello?

Monticello Apartments
Bed Type Average Rent Range
2BR $1,700 $1,600 - $1,850
3BR $1,950 $1,700 - $1,950
Frequently Asked Questions

How many apartments are available in Monticello, NY on Rentable.co?

Rentable.co has over 89 apartments available in Monticello.

What is the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Monticello, NY?

The average rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Monticello is around $1,700 per month.

How expensive is it to rent an apartment in Monticello, NY?

For a two-bedroom apartment in Monticello, the average rent price is $1,700 per month, which is similar to the national average of $1,650 per month.

Can I afford an apartment for rent in Monticello, NY?

Based on average rent prices in Monticello, to afford a two-bedroom apartment you would need an annual household income of $68,000 to live comfortably.

Search Cities Near Monticello, NY

Wurtsboro, NY
Port Jervis, NY
Middletown, NY

Monticello:
March Rent Report

Welcome to the March 2026 Monticello Apartment Report. In this assessment of the local rental market, Rentable data scientists and rental experts break down the March 2026 key findings and figures for the Monticello rental landscape.

Our experts analyze the pricing trends — one-bedroom, two-bedroom, year-over-year and month-over-month — in Monticello and surrounding areas and provide comparisons to the entire metro area, nearby cities and some of the most desirable and expensive cities in the United States. Take a look at the last 12 months of Monticello average rent prices in the chart below.

Monthly Rent Report

$2,000
$1,500
$1,000
$500
$0
Apr. 2025
May. 2025
Jun. 2025
Jul. 2025
Aug. 2025
Sep. 2025
Oct. 2025
Nov. 2025
Dec. 2025
Jan. 2026
Feb. 2026
Mar. 2026
1 BR       2 BR

Monticello Rent Prices Decrease From February to March

Monticello rent prices decreased over the last month. From February to March, the city experienced a 0% decrease for the price of a one-bedroom apartment. The rent price for a Monticello one-bedroom apartments currently stands at $.

When we take a look at the two-bedroom comparison from February to March, Monticello experienced a 0% decrease for the price of a two-bedroom apartment. The rent price for a Monticello two-bedroom apartments currently stands at $.

March Prices: Monticello vs. Surrounding Areas

Rent Prices in Monticello and Surrounding Areas

Rent prices have decreased in Monticello over the last month. But how have the surrounding areas fared when it comes to the recent volatility in apartment prices? Rent prices in 0 of the Monticello suburbs increased last month. On the other hand, 0 local areas experienced a decrease in the price of a one-bedroom apartment.

More key findings include:

  • Rents did not increase in any of the Monticello suburbs

  • Rents did not decrease in any of the Monticello suburbs.

March 2026 Pricing Trends: Monticello vs. National Comparisons

Monticello Rent Prices More Affordable Than Major Cities

Rent growth in Monticello over the past year has been declining. When compared to major cities nearby, along with some of the most expensive cities in the country, Monticello average rent prices appear to be relatively affordable for local residents.

The price for a Monticello one-bedroom apartment remains vastly more affordable than four of the largest cities in the United States — New York City, Washington, D.C. San Francisco and Los Angeles. And pricing compares quite similarly to nearby Midwest cities.

For more information about Monticello and surrounding area rent prices, take a look at the complete data set below.

Data set for Monticello and suburbs

1 BR March 1 BR M/M % Change 2 BR March 2 BR M/M % Change

Methodology

Each month, using over 1 million Rentable listings across the United States, we calculate the median 1-bedroom and 2-bedroom rent prices by city, state, and nation, and track the month-over-month percent change. To avoid small sample sizes, we restrict the analysis for our reports to cities meeting minimum population and property count thresholds.